Please note that the Sports Information Office is continually updating records and requests any additional records not found on this list.
| INDOOR TRACK | All-Time Top Ten by Event | ||
| 55 Meters | Eric Woodruff | 6.37 | ECAC Indoor Championships 3/4/2011 |
| 60 Meters | Eric Woodruff | 6.87 | Lafayette-Rider Winter Games 2/11/2011 |
| 55-Meter Hurdles | Ozzie Brown | 7.43 | ECAC Indoor Championships 3/7/2008 |
| 60-Meter Hurdles | Ozzie Brown | 8.10 | Cornell Invitational 2/9/2008 |
| 200 Meters | Eric Woodruff | 21.55 | Lafayette-Rider Winter Games 2/11/2011 |
| 300 Yards | Ozzie Brown | 32.80 | Lafayette 12/2/2005 |
| 400 Meters | Jeff Cullingford | 49.4 (HT) | 1/10/1990 |
| 500 Meters | Cory Taggert | 1:05:59 | ECAC Championships 3/4/2017 |
| 600 Meters | Jeff Cullingford | 1:13.0 (HT) | 1/26/1990 |
| 800 Meters | Jeff Cullingford | 1:52.10 | 3/10/1990 |
| 1000 Meters | Charlie Hoch | 2:30.06 (HT) | 12/1/1990 - converted from 1,000 yards |
| 1500 Meters | Tim Pfluger | 3:55.4 (HT) | Haverford 2000 |
| Mile | Bryan Kerchner | 4:15.88 | Penn State Tune-Up 2/21/2025 |
| 3000 Meters | Owen Nahf | 8:26.37 | AARTFC Championships 3/2/2024 |
| 5000 Meters | Donald Noble | 14:36.23 | ECAC Championships 3/2/2012 |
| 2 Mile | Tim Pfluger | 9:39.8 (HT) | Lafayette 2000 |
| 3 Mile | Bob Carducci | 15:45.4 (HT) | 1/19/1991 |
| Mile Relay | Hoch, Chadwick, Ziegler, Cullingford | 3:21.41 | 2/26/90 |
| 2 Mile Relay | Kennedy, Chadwick, Cullingford, Hoch | 7:51.2 | 1/29/1989 |
| Distance Medley Relay | Josh Heebner, Tim Pfluger, Damon Rutherford, George Wacker |
10:19.7 | Bucknell 1/29/2000 |
| Sprint Medley Relay | Ziegler, Stamm, O'Neil, Johnson | 3:38.60 | 1/31/1993 |
| 4x176 Relay | O'Neil, Stamm, Ziegler, Martino | 1:15.0 | 2/26/1991 |
| 4x200 Relay | Eric Woodruff, Justin Taylor, Warner Jones, Kyle D'Angelo |
1:30.56 | Landmark Championships 2/26/2011 |
| 4x400 Relay | Hoch, Chadwick, Ziegler, Cullingford | 3:21.41 | 1990 |
| Shot Put | Denzel Pettway | 51-10 1/2 | ECAC Championships 3/5/2016 |
| 35lb. Weight Throw | Tim King | 53-10 1/4 | F&M Mini-Dip Invitational 1/27/2023 |
| High Jump | Dan Reichenbach | 6-9 1/2 | 1/7/1989 |
| Long Jump | Joe Moore | 24-2 1/2 | Kane Invitational 2/15/2003 |
| Triple Jump | Kristopher Joint | 49-6 1/4 | ECAC Championships 3/7/2014 |
| Pole Vault | Ryan Karnopp | 16-6 3/4 | Kutztown Last Chance 2/21/2015 |
| Pentathlon | Greg O'Neil | 3,867 points | 1/23/1994 |
| Heptathlon | David Cariello | 4,725 points | Lehigh Fast Times Before Finals 12/6-7/2013 |
| OUTDOOR TRACK | All-Time Top Ten by Event | ||
| 100 Meters | Eric Woodruff | 10.48 | Greyhound Invitational 4/17/2011 |
| 200 Meters | Eric Woodruff | 20.82 | NYC Qualifying Challenge 5/8/2010 |
| 400 Meters | Jeff Cullingford | 48.0 (HT) | Princeton 5/12/1990 |
| 800 Meters | Jeff Cullingford | 1:49.57 | NCAA's 5/23/1990 |
| 1500 Meters | Greg Jaindl | 3:53.00 | AARTFC Championships 5/20/2021 |
| Steeplechase | Greg Jaindl | 9:03.89 | Swarthmore 5/13/2019 |
| 3000 Meters | Dillon Farrell | 8:42.47 | Lafayette 7-Way Meet 3/29/2015 |
| 5000 Meters | Donald Noble | 14:37.43 | ECAC Championships 5/16/2013 |
| 10000 Meters | Dillon Farrell | 31:05.80 | Sam Howell Memorial Invitational 4/3/2015 |
| 110-Meter High Hurdles | Ozzie Brown | 14.27 | Greyhound Invitational 4/19/2008 |
| 400-Meter Hurdles | Nathaniel Tussey | 52.01 | NCAA Division III Championships 5/22/2008 |
| 4x100 Relay | Jacob Fenstermaker, Trevor Gray, Javon McKay, Owen Sabastro | 41.26 | Widener Final Qualifier 5/13/2024 |
| 4x200 Relay | Austin Gardener, Billy DiLolle, Eric Morton, Cory Taggert | 1:30.27 | Penn Relays 4/28/2017 |
| Sprint Medley Relay (1600) | Austin Gardener, Billy DiLolle, Greg Jaindl, Cory Taggert | 3:32.63 | Penn Relays 4/28/2017 |
| 4x400 Relay | Ziegler, Chadwick, Hoch, Cullingford | 3:13.97 | NCAA's 5/26/1990 |
| 4x800 Relay | Patten, Chadwick, Hoch, Cullingford | 7:40.0 | 4/28/1990 |
| Shot Put | Shane Mastro | 52-10.25 | Princeton Elite 5/14/2022 |
| Discus | Tim King | 153-0 | DeSales Tri-Meet 4/13/2024 |
| Hammer | Dan Jenkins | 166-4 | All-Atlantic Region Championships 5/19/2022 |
| Javelin | Gary Zack | 226-06 | Coach P Open 4/14/2012 |
| Long Jump | Dan Reichenbach | 24-8 1/4 | NCAA's 5/25/1989 |
| Triple Jump | Kristopher Joint | 49-6 1/2 | Muhlenberg Invitational 4/5/2014 |
| High Jump | Dan Reichenbach | 6-10 1/4 | Messiah 4/8/1989 |
| Pole Vault | Timothy Layng | 16-4 3/4 | Coach P Open 4/14/2012 & NCAA Championships 5/26/2012 |
| Decathlon | Ozzie Brown | 7,192 points | NCAA Division III Championships 5/22-23/2008 |